Comments on: Listening to the 20th Century

By: Peter Nelson

Peter Nelson — Mon, 08 Sep 2008 21:07:57 +0000

Please e-mail to me the title of the piece (something like) “Quartet for All Eternity” It had a sub-title with the name “Jesus Christ” in it.

Thanks! I very much liked your show on 20th century music — Sept. 5th. Alas, I’m from New York just driving through Vermont.

Nils Blatz

Nils, you didn’t post an email address so I don’t know how you expect us to email you.

Nonetheless I’m guessing you must be thinking of Messiaen’s Quartet for the End of Time. Messiaen wrote it as a POW of the Germans in WWII. The last movement is entitled “Praise to the Immortality of Jesus”.

By: Nils Blatz

Nils Blatz — Mon, 08 Sep 2008 20:35:48 +0000

Please e-mail to me the title of the piece (something like) “Quartet for All Eternity” It had a sub-title with the name “Jesus Christ” in it.

Thanks! I very much liked your show on 20th century music — Sept. 5th. Alas, I’m from New York just driving through Vermont.

Nils Blatz

By: James Orleans

James Orleans — Sun, 07 Sep 2008 05:34:04 +0000

Some wonderful composers too rarely mentioned or performed:

Ades, Bax, Berg, Bennett (Richard Rodney), Birtwistle, Blomdahl, Baciewicz (sic), Baird, Constant, Carter, Dutilleux, Egge, Fine, Fortner, Gerhard, Genzmer, Hamilton (Iain), Hartmann, Henze, Hindemith, Honegger, Imbrie, Jolivet, Janacek, Krenek, Lindberg, Lutoslawski, Martin, Martinu, Maxwell-Davies, Maw, Mennin, Macmillan, Nigg, Panufnik, Penderecki, Porter (Quincy), Rautavaara, Rochberg, Sessions, Schuman (William), Skalkottas, Sallinen, Shchedrin, Schnittke, Serocki, Szymanowski, Tippett, Turnage, Toch, Urbanner, Wuorinen.

There really is too much good new music not getting played. Time to make a little room in the repertoire by discontinuing the lesser works by the 18th and 19th Century blokes.

By: Andrew Sichel

Andrew Sichel — Sat, 06 Sep 2008 03:10:26 +0000

What a wonderful program and what an informed and articulate man Mr. Ross is.
His suggestion of a healthy fusion of past and present is very timely.I was so taken with this broadcast that I listened to it a second time. I look forward to reading the book. I’m sure that Mr. Ross discusses in the book the intense study and influence of Indian and in Reich’s case also African music for Riley, Reich. Glass, and Young, I would venture more than pop and jazz which Mr. Ross sited on air along with Psychedlia the latter leading these wonderful musicians east, the eastern influence was at the heart of their innovation along with their awareness of music and art history and the Modernist tradition in which they fall.
The sixties along with the word liberalism have taken badly unwarranted beatings. As far as the arts are concerned the sixties was the last renascent cauldron for modern art. What has happened since owes as much a debt to the sixties as to the teens and twenties in Europe are accorded.
Although Reich went west after Cornell and then Julliard it is worth noting that Glass and Young are also both basically east coasters. The concerts Mr. Ross mentioned as influential to The Velvet Underground etc. happened more in NY than out west I believe. In the sixties and seventies New York was as full of Hippies and political radicals as California.
As the election season heats up it is worth mentioning for younger listeners and voters that Modernism, and the history of significant American “high” art or in this case “classical” music, is, as Mr. Ross referenced with Aaron Copeland, definitely a Left wing or Liberal history. I feel safe in saying that with the exception of the Nazi collaborators mentioned none of the composers discussed in this broadcast would’ve or would be caught dead voting Republican. Let’s not be fooled again! Vote Obama/Biden and maybe our country can get back some of that good old love, peace and happiness.
Andrew Sichel
AndrewSichel.blogspot.com

By: Peter Nelson

Peter Nelson — Fri, 05 Sep 2008 19:19:13 +0000

for example, not Shostakovich’s Fifth Symphony but one of his string quartets. I think that one way into 20th century music is thru these smaller, more intimate works. Maybe Alex can recommend some favorite works and performers?

I dunno. I am a big chamber music fan, myself, but when I mention this to others, many people, including college-educated NPR-listening people, often say “what’s chamber music?”. One thing about an orchestral piece is that it’s a format most people are familiar with, even if they’ve never actually been to one.

I love Shostakovich but I’m not so sure his chamber works are fundamentally different or more accessible than his orchestral works. To me his piano quintet in G minor, Op 57 actually reminds me of his 5th Symphony.

One of the problems with much 20th century music, in general, is the same as with 20th century poetry and visual art. (my wife is a classical pianist; I’m a painter and poet) It often written for some elite cognoscenti or group of initiates who “get” the concept. And that’s the problem – there’s usually some overintellectualized concept to get. The success of the composer or artist is often measured, not in how the work speaks to us or makes us feel, but whether he successfully executed his concept.

By: John Holdren

John Holdren — Fri, 05 Sep 2008 15:36:48 +0000

When Alex Ross’s name appears in the table of contents of the New Yorker, I turn to his article first. Thanks for playing the selection from the Quartet for the End of Time. When I pull a CD of 20th-century music from my collection to listen to, it’s less likely to be one of the big orchestral works that get most of the attention, but instead a chamber or instrumental piece — for example, not Shostakovich’s Fifth Symphony but one of his string quartets. I think that one way into 20th century music is thru these smaller, more intimate works. Maybe Alex can recommend some favorite works and performers?

John Holdren, Greenwood, Virginia

By: Chris Goodwin

Chris Goodwin — Fri, 05 Sep 2008 15:19:10 +0000

What was the name of the Schoenberg piece featured in this segment, please? It’s wonderful!